An Echelon Media Company
Saturday December 10th, 2022

Lanka’s cultural sperm whale

Lankan waters harbour four especially charismatic whales and dolphins: sperm whale, blue whale, orca and bottlenose dolphin. Scientists now know unmistakably that all four, along with other cetaceans, maintain and rely on cultures—behaviours socially learned within communities—in order to thrive.

Hallmarks of social learning include imitation and teaching. Socially learned behaviour, neither genetically wired nor acquired through individual experience alone, prevails in environments and niches that vary continually but not too wildly or quickly. In highly stable environments and niches, social learning goes unneeded: behaviour genetically encoded through natural selection suffices for survival. In highly fluctuating environments and niches, on the other hand, social learning can gain no foothold: any potentially helpful culture offers no real advantage if circumstances change radically over the lifespan of a single animal.

The cetacean hunting and foraging lifestyle seem to hit the intermediate culture-favouring sweet spot, in world oceans fluctuating constantly but in discernible patterns. Meaningful and useful knowledge can propagate horizontally among peers and vertically between generations. Cetacean culture capitalizes also on mammalian big brains and social bonding, along with energy levels fueled by breathing oxygen-rich air, unlike fish.

Cetaceans originated some 50 million years ago (mya) in Sri Lanka’s general neighbourhood, diverging from even-toed ungulates (mammals with hooves), an order comprising present-day pigs, camels, sheep, cattle, giraffe and deer. Tell-tale early fossils lie in the high Himalayas, lifted there as India slammed into Asia, beginning also around 50 mya and continuing since then. The earliest known cetacean was a smallish deer-like creature spending some of its time in freshwater streams that flooded seasonally.

By and by, cetaceans learned to swim, at first in fresh water, spending more and more time chasing fish while returning to land for sleep, mating, birthing and nursing, like today’s seals and walrus. At 40 mya, some renounced land entirely and began dispersing through global seas. Their forelimbs became flippers while their hind legs shrank into vestiges. At around 35 mya, odontocetes (toothed whales and dolphins) began their voyage toward ocean’s top predatorship. Among these odontocetes, early sperm whales emerged maybe 20 mya and the notorious monster Livyatan around 10 mya. About the size of modern sperm whales, preying on whales and seals, it sported bigger biting teeth than any other animal ever. It fell extinct around 5 mya, possibly because of prey scarcity linked to global cooling, the same fate that may have met its contemporary giant shark, Megalodon. Except in size, today’s sperm whale lies closer to early odontocete forms than do other modern odontocetes like orca and bottlenose.

At 17 to 20 pounds, the sperm whale brain is the largest of any creature ever: evidence of high intelligence though her brain/ body weight ratio does not match ours. She scores high in sociability as well. We understand more and more that high intelligence in vertebrates correlates with high sociability. Nimbleness in navigating complex social spaces requires, rewards and nurtures braininess. One observer contends that sperm whales “have the most complex social structure of any animal other than man.”

Like elephants, sperm whales typically move in clusters of juveniles and mature females who share in care for the young. When mommy dives for food, she leaves her calf with babysitting female relatives. Aunties suckle one another’s babies. Such ‘alloparenting’ (caregiving to youngsters by aunties, assisting mothers) fosters sociability and intelligence by exposing juveniles to a variety of key relationships. Among nurturing females as well, networks of trust, communication and exchange of favours grow dense. Neuronal connections likewise.

Sperm whales dine mainly on squid, which they find at incredible depths. Routinely diving 500 meters, she can reach as deep as three kilometres, perhaps more, attaining dive speed up to 175 meters per minute. Abrasive squid beaks in her digestive system may be what triggers her to produce an intestinal lubricant called ambergris, a gummy, buoyant, pungently aromatic substance prized for perfumes. She excretes it in faeces and vomits. In contrast with Livyatan’s massive meat-shredding choppers, the modern cousin sports rudimentary teeth only on her bottom jaw. Scientists think she does not even use them for killing. Instead, she stuns prey with shatteringly loud buzzes, squeaks and clicks before swallowing them whole, dead or alive.

As she dives, her blood and muscles favour her with stupendous oxygen-carrying and -storage capacity, enabling her to stay down for as long as two hours without surfacing. She feeds in the deepest darkness and crushing pressure from the water above. Sound is her only useful sense in the deep she prowls. She gulps down maybe 600 squids daily, finding her prey by echolocation, like bats. Emitting recurring sonar clicks, she ‘sees’ other creatures from rippling wrinkles in the rebounding sound. Hers is probably the loudest animal sound on earth (blue whale song is its only possible rival), amplified and focused somehow through those huge spermaceti chambers in her ‘forehead’ and then echoed back through those chambers, transmitted to the brain and deciphered as imagery. (Some experts contend that spermaceti also helps regulate buoyancy.) It was of course spermaceti, prized for lubricants, lamp oil and candles, that drove humans to hunt her to the brink of extinction.

Sri Lanka is one of the best places in the world to see sperm whales because they come in close to shore here within range of whale-watching boats, and it may be the best place to see sperm whale ‘superpods’—dozens to hundreds assembled and visible at the same time. A gathering off Trincomalee in March 2012 may have numbered up to 250. Since then, superpods of up to 350 animals have appeared several times offshore in the Gulf of Mannar, mostly during March and April. Lanka may in fact be the only place on earth to witness these gatherings regularly. They may happen every year.

The likeliest explanation is mating. The whales prefer warm water for mating and maybe Lanka is especially easy for everyone to find. Calm (inter monsoonal) seas, plenty of space: Gulf of Mannar. The Gulf’s shallow waters, averaging only six meters, maybe a feature, not a bug. They obviously preclude deep-dive hunting. But I strongly suspect that the creatures go without food during the mating season anyway, though I have found no supporting sources. (Other cetacean species do fast during mating season.) The surface is where the action lies.

Because they spend so much time beneath the surface of the open ocean far from land, we know very little about sperm whales. Their first-ever underwater footage, taken in Lankan waters as it happens, came only in 1984. Once a day or so, they like to lie at the surface, amiably socializing: lying quietly side by side and nuzzling one another or ‘vocalizing (they actually lack vocal chords) back and forth. If mating is indeed the key, we may begin to grasp wild behaviors during superpods: jaw clapping, tail elevation, tail slapping, belly-ups, roll-overs, head raises, spy hopping (head up, tail down) and breaching—flinging themselves clear of the water. Flirt much?

YouTube video from Lankan waters a few years back murkily captures a savage attack by a pack of orca (killer whales) upon a grouping of sperm whales. Though the prey appears to escape after a few minutes, observers smell blood from their boat. When orcas threaten, sperm whales encircle their young or vulnerable in cooperative formation. They may face inward, presenting a firing line of powerful tail flukes outward against assailants, or they may face outward with their dangerous-toothed jaws. They protect each other and each other’s young even at high peril to themselves. Entire families will strand themselves on a beach so as to solace a stricken relative. Behavior like this leads some to call sperm whales ‘elephants of the sea.’ Their intense social bonding came to the aid of their human hunters. Where you find one sperm whale you’ll probably find several and they’ll hang with each other even in the face of obvious danger. Slaughter made easy.

As indicated, sperm whale juveniles and adult females spend bulks of their time in matrilineal pods, numbering 10-20 animals or so, all related to one another. Aside from echolocation clicks, they communicate among themselves with variable code-like click sequences called codas, each sequence lasting about a second in total. They toss these sequences back and forth in duets and join them together in choruses. This undoubtedly deepens their bonding. Youngsters learn these codas from grown-ups, along with movement and migration strategies, habitat knowledge and hunting techniques. As they mature females pass these learned behaviors along to upcoming generations of young.

Males of a certain age will depart the pod and take up with other males, often in clusters. They migrate toward the poles, leaving warm waters to aunties and juveniles, but return to the tropics for mating. Among companionate male groupings, fads of novel behaviour arise and sometimes fade away to be supplanted by others. Reminds me of my son and his buddies. Males in the Gulf of Alaska have taught one another to nibble yummy black cod off fishing longline hooks, leaving less tasty fish behind.

Aside from smallish kin-based pods and possibly non-kin-based male groups, juveniles and grown females adhere to particular multi-pod ‘clans’ numbering thousands of animals spread across huge swathes of sea. These communities share among themselves the same repertoire of codas, distinct from those of other clans. These dialects are precisely what define the boundaries between clans. Clan ‘membership’ turns not on kinship, except that within participating pods, but also not on geographical proximity. Clan members range in their smaller groupings over thousands of kilometres. They recognise and greet fellow clan members but seldom or never socialize outside their own clan. They inhabit patches of the sea alongside other clans, ignoring and avoiding those others perpetually. It’s Hogwarts without inter-house quidditch. We don’t seem to know much about whether males stick tightly with clan fellows or roam with chums from other clans.

Concomitant with their separate dialects, clans differ in their movement patterns, feeding success and likelihood of offspring. If it precludes interbreeding, such cultural separation could conceivably drive the evolution of distinct species. Separation into clans might be nature’s way of seeking Darwinian ‘fitness’ among sperm whales. Some might speculate that sperm whale clans already represent distinct sub-species. We don’t know yet and probably won’t for a long time. Speciation gets retarded to the extent that males mate outside their natal clans. They sometimes do but we don’t know how much.

Cultural differentiation seems most markedly true of Pacific sperm whales and probably applies to those clustering in Lankan superpods, given the ease of travel between the Pacific and Indian Oceans. This raises the question of how much inter-clan mating takes place in our offshore gatherings. Avoidance of interbreeding might at first glance suggest a benefit to inter-clan mating, but clans are not primarily kin-based in the first place. Mutual incomprehension among dialects might preclude mixed mating, but then again as we’ve seen, the creatures seem to have other ways of conveying erotic interest and attractiveness.

It will be a while before we can answer this question one way or the other, but I’ll venture a guess that females and juveniles populating any given superpod hail from the same clan. Whether they seek or shun males from other clans will govern any possible transition from clan to subspecies to separate species. Males compete and fight for mating opportunities. Do they gang up on males from other clans? Move along, pal, you can find your own peeps down the coast there a bit.

Braininess, sociability, cooperation and communication in distinct dialects: all seem inevitable to raise the question of language. Do sperm whales possess it? A well-funded five-year study currently endeavours to answer that question and to decipher sperm whale ‘language.’ The Cetacean Translation Initiative (CETI: a pun on both ‘cetacean’ and ‘SETI,’ Search for ExtraTerrestrial Intelligence) combines extensive recordings of communications; computer-aided pattern-seeking in those recordings; and notations on related situations and behaviour. The website coyly toggles between referring to ‘communication’ and to ‘language.’ CETI’s ultimate dream is conversing with the whales. CETI’s chief, marine biologist David Gruber, looks forward with wide eyes in a TED talk to a day when we discover sperm whales discussing something that happened ‘yesterday.’ Feel like sending money?

Understanding more about sperm whale communication seems eminently worthwhile. But the idea of learning their ‘language’ will likely end up a nothing burger. Among many theories of human language evolution, a key one posits toolmaking and tool use as the driver: the ability to transmit tool knowledge across populations and down through generations. Such would be a crucial advantage for our upright-walking, vulnerable, savannah predator ancestors. Scientists point to substantial overlap between human brain sectors governing language and tool manipulation. That whales could be substantial tool users seems vanishingly unlikely. Sperm whales can hold their breath a long time but we should not hold ours hoping to swap stories with them.

Further Reading

  • Whitehead & Rendell, The Cultural Lives of Whales and Dolphins
  • Hoare, Leviathan or the Whale
  • Beale, The Natural History of the Sperm Whale
  • Mann, Deep Thinkers
  • Pyenson, Spying on Whales
  • Melville, Moby Dick

Organizations and Resources

  • Centre for Research on Indian Ocean Marine Mammals (CRIOMM)(Sri Lanka)
  • Sri Lanka’s Amazing Maritime (SLAM)(Sri Lanka) NOAA Fisheries, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (USA)
  • Whale and Dolphin Conservation (WDC)(UK) Marine Mammal Institute, Oregon State University (USA)

Whale Watching

  • Borderlands, Weligama
  • Mirissa Water Sports, Mirissa
  • Raja and the Whales, Mirissa
  • Royal Tours, Mirissa

Lawyer, writer and former law professor, Mark Hager lives in Pelawatte with his family.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a Comment

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sri Lanka opposition MP sees racist agenda behind behind pro-China demonstration

TNA MP Shanakiya Rasamanickam – Image credit: Facebook

ECONOMYNEXT – A protest held outside the Chinese embassy in Colombo against opposition legislator Shanakiyan Rasamanickam was likely the work of a paid group with little knowledge of Sri Lanka’s crisis and pushing someone else’s racist agenda, the MP said.

Rasamanickam told EconomyNext on Saturday December 10 that the protestors were peddling a familiar narrative of racism.

“These people are clearly on a racist agenda. We know how this agenda plays out and we know who is behind it from before, so it’s not anything new. People can connect the dots and figure out who might be behind this protest,” he said.

The hurriedly put together demonstration seemed to be against Rasamanickam’s controversial warnings of anti-China protests in Sri Lanka over Beijing’s purported reluctance to restructure the crisis-hit island nation’s debt.

A small group of protestors including a number of Buddhist monks had gathered outside the embassy premises on Friday December 09 condemning Rasamanickam’s statement in parliament that people will take to the streets against China in a “go home, China” wave of protests similar to the “go home, Gota” protests that unseated Sri Lanka’s powerful former president Gotabaya Rajapaksa.

“I was actually very happy to see a protest happening against me in Colombo. This is the first time there was a protest held against me,” said Rasamanickam.

I”f you look at the group that were protesting, they are quite unaware of the current economic situation in the island,” he added.

One banner displayed by the pro-China protestors contained the words “let us strongly condemn the ‘Go home China’ statement by separatist Rasamanickam” in Sinhala, though the organisers had been careful to omit the word ‘separatist’ in the English translation of the slogan.

It is unclear at present who was behind the protest, but a placard carried by one of the protestors read “is this going from anti-Gota to anti-China”, indicating the possible involvement of pro-Rajapaksa elements.

“It looked like a paid  group of people who came with no knowledge of the country’s situation and was completely under the agenda of somebody else,” said the MP.

The Batticaloa district lawmaker claimed that some people had offered to organise a counter-protest against the pro-China demonstrators but he declined the offer.

“I refused it because the citizens aren’t silly. They are aware of their surroundings and what is going on, so we need not protest in that way,” he said.

A commotion also ensued at the demonstration when a woman started recording it on her mobile phone, prompting some of the protestors to demand that she leave. Words were exchanged, with the visibly agitated woman yelling at the protestors that they were conspiring to sell Sri Lanka to China.

What triggered the protest was an explosive remark by MP Rasamanickam on December 02 that if China were a true friend of Sri Lanka’s, it would agree to either write off the island nation’s 7.4 billion dollar debt or at least help restructure it.

Nearly a fifth of Sri Lanka’s public external debt is held by China, according to one calculation.

“If China, who has nearly 20,000 billion dollars, is truly Sri Lanka’s friend… offering 9 million litres of diesel or half a million kilos of rice isn’t real help,” said Rasamanickam, speaking in Sinhala.

“I say to China and the Chinese embassy that, as 22 million Sri Lankans irrespective of ethnic or religious differences got together to say ‘Go home, Gota’, don’t push us to a place where we will be saying ‘China, go home’,” he said.

Whatever the agenda behind Friday’s protestors, they are not alone in their opposition to Rasamanickam’s strong words against China. Main opposition Samagi Jana Balawegaya (SJB) MP Harsha de Silva was strongly critical of the statement, insisting that Sri Lanka cooperate with all countries.

Rasamanickam told EconomyNext that his words were misrepresented.

“What I said was ex President Gotabaya Rajapaksa didn’t listen to the voices of the people and people ended up saying ‘Gota Go Home’ and if the Chinese fail to address the issues and act in the interest of the Sri Lankan community, naturally people will start opposing them also. If that happens, I simply said that I will support them because for us our country and our people are the priority,” he said, adding that his speech had raised awareness among the public of the situation.

The MP has been raising his voice in parliament and elsewhere in recent days over what he claims is a hesitance on the part of China to assist in Sri Lanka’s debt restructuring efforts. The 2.9 billion dollar extended fund facility (EFF) that the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has offered to extend to the island nation is contingent upon the successful restructure of this outstanding in addition some stringent reforms that experts say are long overdue.

Colombo has been vague at best on the status of ongoing restructure talks with Sri Lanka’s creditors, and opposition lawmakers and others have expressed concern over what seems to be a worrying delay. Rasamanickam and others have claimed that China, Sri Lanka’s largest bilateral creditor, is the reason for the apparent standstill.

Meanwhile, IMF Chief Kristalina Georgieva has called on China to speed up restructuring of debt in Sri Lanka and Zambia following a meeting with the leaders of the country.

“We had a very fruitful exchange, both on the G20 Common Framework and on some specific cases,” she said in a statement after the meeting.

“We need to build on the momentum of the agreement on Chad’s debt treatment and accelerate and finalize the debt treatments for Zambia and Sri Lanka, which would allow for disbursements from the IMF and multilateral development banks,” she said. (Colombo/Dec10/2022)

Continue Reading

IMF chief calls on China to speed up Sri Lanka, Zambia debt overhaul

ECONOMYYNEXT- International Monetary Fund Chief Kristalina Georgieva has called on China to speed up restructuring of debt in Sri Lanka and Zambia following a meeting with the leaders of the country.

“We had a very fruitful exchange, both on the G20 Common Framework and on some specific cases,” she said in a statement after the meeting.

“We need to build on the momentum of the agreement on Chad’s debt treatment and accelerate and finalize the debt treatments for Zambia and Sri Lanka, which would allow for disbursements from the IMF and multilateral development banks.”

Sri Lanka is discussions with the Export Import Bank of China as the lead lender to the island, State Minister Shehan Semasinghe told parliament.

China has informed Sri Lanka that they will also hold bilateral discussions with the IMF and World Bank he said.

China has been asking questions from Sri Lanka and lenders were trying to assess the impact on credits to other countries as well as the domestic economy, he said.

China is a top lender to Sri Lanka along with Japan, the Asian Development Bank and Japan.

Some of China’s infrastructure loans have also been questioned for lack of proper feasibility, though a coal plant is generally acknowledged to be best investment the country has made since the 1980s and is enough to cover many since.

But China gave several so-called ‘cover up loans’ to Sri Lanka which was not linked to infrastructure or economic reforms when the country ran into forex shortages under ‘flexible inflation targeting/output gap targeting’ compounding borrowings from sovereign bond investors.

Sri Lanka calls such monetary instability linked borrowings ‘bridging finance’.

The World Bank and Asian Development Bank or Japan does not give such ‘bridging finance’ or budget support loans without reforms to expand economic activities.

Sri Lanka central government net debt (after deducting foreign reserves) which was 17 billion US dollars after almost 65 years of foreign borrowings shot up to 32 billion US dollars over 7 years of extreme monetary instability. Meanwhile foreign reserves became negative.

Resorting foreign borrowings to meet foreign repayments comes from a Mercantilist fallacy known as the ‘transfer problem’, analysts have said.


Sri Lanka debt crisis trapped in spurious Keynesian ‘transfer problem’ and MMT: Bellwether

Policy makers believe that a current account surplus is magically required to make foreign repayments and not higher interest rates to curtail domestic investments and consumption which make resources available to meet such payments which will in turn reduce the imports and any current account deficit. (Colombo/Dec10/2022)

Continue Reading

Sri Lanka has excess rice amid malnutrition: President

ECONOMYNEXT – Sri Lanka is to harvest a good rice harvest in the upcoming main (Maha) cultivation season but paddy stocks from two previous seasons are still with farmers and collectors, President Ranil Wickremesinghe said.

“I see now that we will get a good harvest in the Maha season,” President Ranil Wickremesinghe told parliament.

“That is also a problem, because we have some leftover rice stocks from the recent Yala (minor) season and the previous Maha season.”

“Now there can be situation of excess rice, we have to protect the farmers. On the other had we will have food to reduce malnutrition.”

Sri Lanka’s rice farmers do not grow and internationally traded grade of rice and bumper harvests do not lead to export booms but calls for trade restrictions on the hungry and helpless to ‘protect’ their incomes.

Rough rice (paddy) prices have fallen to around 80 rupees a kilogram, from over 120 rupees at the height of the crisis earlier in the year when large volumes of money was injected to the banking system to sterilize interventions and pay state workers.

Food Price Crisis

Though supplies are coming back to normal, because soft-pegging macro-economists destroyed the rupee from 200 to 360 to the US dollar by printing money for two years to keep interest rates down, prices are double before from the liquidity injections or ‘stimulus’ started.

The malnutrition is coming from monetary instability involving the collapse of the anchor-conflicting ‘flexible exchange rate and not a problem in the real economy as excess food supplies show.

Related Impoverished Sri Lankans are selling assets, eating less: WFP

Sri Lanka’s chicken farmers are also looking for export opportunities.

Related Sri Lanka chicken farmers eye exports as domestic prices drop

Sri Lanka is now in the worst the worst currency crisis triggered it the history of its intermediate regime (flexible exchange rate) central bank.

With salaries not keeping pace, incomes many sectors, mostly salaried workers including daily wage earners are too low to afford food whether or not they are plentiful, leading to malnutrition especially of the children of poor families.

The phenomenon has a been a recurring problem in the country after the soft-pegged central bank was set up 72 years ago.

Before 1980, when depreciation became fashionable in Washington policy making circles (now called a flexible exchange rate and BBC policy at that time), import controls were the main threat to food supplies, not soaring prices and lagging wages.

Food Trade Controls

In the 2022 currency crisis soft-pegging macro-economist in a mistaken strategy then banned ‘open account imports’ threatening food supplies ranging from lentils to onions and sugar to wheat that usually come from South Asia and Dubai, driving up prices.

But Wickremesinghe then opened account imports, preventing a real food crisis from taking place, allowing money flowing through traditional gross settlement systems (Undiyal/Hawala) to be easily prioritized for food.


Sri Lanka can trigger food shortages as in medicines with new trade controls

Sri Lanka food importers seek exemption from open account trade ban

Sri Lanka removes ban on open account food imports

Food imports in Sri Lanka are only around 100 to 150 million dollars a month which is about third of monthly worker remittances and about 10 percent of total exports.

However the central bank under Governor Nandalal Weerasinghe took the required action to liberalize rates allowing credit to slow and stabilize the external sector.

The government also raised energy prices to keep in line with flexible exchange rate collapse (also a recurring phenomenon) and raised taxes to reduce domestic credit (also recurring action).

President Wickremesinghe and his advisors focused their efforts on getting loans from foreign lenders to buy fertilizer for farmers after he took over as Prime Minister and later President.

Fertilizer supplies are important in a currency crisis not just to produce food as normal but the construction sector usually has to be smashed to stop balance of payments deficits and to stop the rupee from falling further.

When rural workers engaged in construction return home to farming areas availability of fertilizer will help them keep in employment.

Open Market Injections

Construction and other sectors undergo an artificial boom when a soft-pegging central bank suppresses rates with its open market operations and sells downs reserves when the currency peg comes under pressure.

Selling reserves and printing money through open market operations to stop rates going up – an action called ‘sterilized intervention’ – effectively injects what classical economists called ‘fictitious capital’ into banks and artificially pushing up credit and imports further by effectively re-financing private sector activities with central bank credit.

The new money to sterilize interventions over-extending a credit cycle and encourages more imports.

In the current crisis Sri Lanka’s Consumer Affairs Authority, by imposing price controls, disrupted sectors like poultry sector and created black markets.

President Wickremesinghe has so far not taken any actions to abolish the CAA or its price controlling powers which goes against his ‘social market economy’ strategy. (Colombo/Dec09/2022)

Continue Reading